…yeah. Here’s the Top 13: 1. Philip Phillips 2. Hollie Cavanagh 3. Jessica Sanchez 4. Joshua Ledet 5. Heejun Han 6. Shannon Magrane 7. Skylar Laine 8. Elise Testone 9. Colton Dixon 10. Jermaine Jones 11. Erika Van Pelt 12. Jeremy Rosado 13. Deandre Brackensick



ratings this year are the lowest since season 1 and 2 @televisionsoup
BUT- I will agree with @TheGamer32121 that Reed seriously disappointed me with his wildcard performance. That was NOT singing for your life there. He barely even sang? He really should’ve focused on showing off his killer vocals there and he didn’t. Pity.
Reed and Jen were my FAVORITES. and I was just floored that they didn’t make it. I just feel like it’s the same with Casey Abrams. People just don’t understand their styles/voices and that really upsets me.
I like Iovine! He was the best part of the night!
Go Phillip he is so good singing in person… Saw him by chance and just loved him… only heard two songs because he finished before we finished eating at the Chilli’s we were at but he is just great and I am so glad he made it……So what Stevie song should he sing next week….I guess he can’t sing his audition song so what……rich
My very top bracket #1 are Phillip Phillips, Jessica Sanchez and Hollie Cavanaugh (I may be wrong with the spelling). #2 bracket are Dixson Colton, Van Pelt and Heejun Han.
LOVE fleet foxes!!! i would love to hear him do “meadowlarks”
if you don’t care, don’t watch.
@TheGamer32121 well said. Totally agree.
colton far better than reed in the final perforamnce, maybe try stop favouring people and open your ears. We Dont Really care if you stop watching. Jen and Reed wild card performances werent not up to par and you know it.
Am I the only one who really liked Chelsea and did not think it was fair that they never showed her and basically took her out of the competition even though her performance was better than half of the rest…. Really left me wantting more.
Oh yeah and Colton is awesome. So who cares about your TOP BRACKET and whether or not you’re happy. Your video updates could frankly be watched on the American Idol website anyway.
Honestly who cares if you don’t watch anymore. You’re CRAZY for thinking Reed should be in. His scatting crap was not good at all. JEREMY WAS A GREAT PIC. He will make it farther than Heejun and Jermaine. They are not good. I think Aaron should’ve made it over Jermaine.
I didn’t see his performance so I couldn’t tell you. But in most cases, I get your point in the fact that America usually drops the ball when the Top 12/13 is revealed. For example, Season 9; aside from Crystal and Siobhan, that was the worst top 12 ever put together by America. If they put in Baylie, Brielle, and Haley in, that would’ve been three strikes.
if you think erika was weak then you don’t really know much about singing… i agree with you about jeremy and deandre i think that jen and creighton should have made it but erika deserves to be there 100% and personally she deserves to go all the way.
To be completely honest, Jen Hirsh was really only decent. I think many people mistake that breathy style of singing she does as “soul” but, she really just doesn’t have any of the “soul” that she’s been said to have. Her cover of Oh Darling! Was also severely lacking in that she did a little bit too much to the point that she was over singing a tad bit. While I had enjoyed Reed Grimm’s original performance of “Moves Like Jagger”, I felt that his wildcard performance was terrible. Glad he’s out.
Not really you think Jermain was a smart choice? lol America fails as usual
I think America got it right. Vocally, Reed was weaker than Joshua, Deandre, Jeremy, Philip, Heejun, Colton, and even Jermaine. The judges had to be fair Mollie and pick who was doing the wildcards who had done best at the live shows (Deandre, Erika, and Jeremy). Jen’s performances were good but lacked substance and it just seems like she sounded the same each time. I agree with the judges and America. But that’s just me.
I agree with you. They should have switched Jeremy and Colton with Reed and Jen.
of course you support a WGWG :/
I’m glad that Erika and Deandre got 2 of the wild cards…but the 3rd wild card should have gone to Jen or Brielle (she reminds me of Haley Reinhart…and I loved Haley).
dont care too much about reed. i dont like jermaine either.
i think the girls are spot on… jessica, hollie, skylar, elise, and erika are awesome. shannon could have been switched up with jen or hallie but i dont care too much about the three.
think heejun and phillip have a bromance
honestly, they made a mistake. what, budget cuts or something??? WHY CUT SO MANY PEOPLE, IDOL?? WHY. CUT. SO. MANY. PEOPLE. honestly, “most talented year”? you’re not really showcasing that cause like……………………………………………..you cut 12 people.